Das Buch gibt einen Überblick über den Verlauf des Amtsenthebungsverfahrens gegen Donald Trump und analysiert dabei die Wahrnehmung des Verfahrens. Why Was Donald Trump Impeached: Election Theme Notebook Journal Schoolbook | Walford, Jenny | ISBN: | Kostenloser Versand für. Now that Trump is impeached, See what lies ahead for Americans. The full House of Representatives voted on December 18, on articles of impeachment.
Impeachment: Trump triumphiert im US-SenatDas Impeachment-Verfahren gegen Donald J. Trump. Der Republikaner (R) Donald J. Trump genießt die zweifelhafte Ehre, der erste US-. Niederlage für die Demokraten: Sie wollten im Impeachment-Verfahren gegen Donald Trump auch Zeugen hören. Erfolglos. Das Votum fiel. Im Impeachment-Verfahren hätten die meisten Republikaner hinter Donald Trump gestanden, sagte Politikberater Peter Rough im Dlf. Denn es.
Trump Impeached Navigation menu VideoThe phone call that could get Trump impeached Die Demokraten fürchten, dass die Republikaner das alles Gratis Roulette Spielen ihrer Senatsmehrheit verhindern werden. Wir verwenden Cookies, um unser Angebot für Sie zu verbessern. Mehr Infos Okay. Mehr zu diesem Thema: Impeachment: "Trump hat seinen Eid verraten",
Einen Trump Impeached. - InhaltsverzeichnisKonflikt um Rundfunkbeitrag Politik will entscheiden, wie über sie berichtet wird.
Diese Bedingungen sind StrafstoГџ Regeln und mГssen vollstГndig erfГllt werden. - Entdecken Sie den DeutschlandfunkEr rief die Demokraten am Party Spiele Erwachsene Dienstagabend Ortszeit auf, gebündelt über die Anträge abzustimmen und die Dinge so zu beschleunigen. His poll Realize Deutsch sunk a point or two when the Ukraine news initially broke but seem to have rebounded back as the impeachment process went on. Adam Schiff is the chair of the House Intelligence Committee, unofficial leader of the multi-committee impeachment inquiry, and over the years, a frequent anti-Trump talking head on television. Archived from the original on December 17,
Two Democrats — Reps. Jeff Van Drew, of New Jersey, and Collin Peterson, of Minnesota — voted against impeaching Trump for abuse of power, along with all of the members of the Republican minority.
Jared Gordon, of Maine, split his vote, voting for abuse of power, but against obstruction of congresss. The Democratic majority was joined by Rep.
Justin Amash , of Michigan, a former Republican who turned independent. On the first article of impeachment, the House voted to Democratic Rep. Tulsi Gabbard, of Hawaii, abstained by voting present.
Gabbard, who is running for president has been critical of the impeachment process and had called for Trump to be censured instead of an impeachment vote.
On the second article of impeachment, the House voted to , with Gabbard again voting present. Earlier in the day, Trump left the White House without making a statement or taking questions from reporters.
Without receiving a single Republican vote, and without providing any proof of wrongdoing, Democrats pushed illegitimate articles of impeachment against the President through the House of Representatives.
Democrats have chosen to proceed on this partisan basis in spite of the fact that the President did absolutely nothing wrong.
Indeed, weeks of hearings have proved that he did nothing wrong. The House blatantly ignored precedent and conducted the inquiry in secrecy behind closed doors so that Chairman Adam Schiff and his partisan political cronies could selectively leak information to their partners in the media to push a false narrative.
After an exhaustive effort failed to convince Speaker Nancy Pelosi and others that they had reason to impeach, a new scandal emerged that succeeded in doing so.
In September , the public learned of a whistleblower complaint regarding a July phone call between Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.
The complaint, which was corroborated by the acting Ambassador to Ukraine, stated that Trump had threatened to withhold U.
The White House denied any "quid pro quo. After both articles were approved in the House, the case then moved to a Senate trial, which began on January 16, Supreme Court chief justice John Roberts presided over the trial.
No pressure and, unlike Joe Biden and his son, NO quid pro quo! This is nothing more than a continuation of the Greatest and most Destructive Witch Hunt of all time!
Separately, a member of the intelligence community who filed a whistleblower complaint about a conversation or multiple conversations Mr Trump had with Mr Zelensky, has indicated he or she wants to testify before Congress.
It should soon become clear whether the whiff of scandal swirling around this story is overblown, or really is as serious as it seems. The House Judiciary Committee would then draft and approve articles of impeachment, to be voted on by the House of Representatives.
The Democrats control the numbers in the House, but at the moment, fewer than of them actually support the impeachment inquiry.
More would have to come on board. Donald Trump is the third U. Congress's first efforts to impeach Trump were initiated by Democratic representatives Al Green and Brad Sherman in Following the elections, the Democrats gained a majority in the House and launched multiple investigations into Trump's actions and finances.
In May , however, she indicated that Trump's continued actions, which she characterized as obstruction of justice and refusal to honor congressional subpoenas, might make an impeachment inquiry necessary.
Investigations into various scandals in the Trump administration which could lead to articles of impeachment were initiated by various house congressional committees, led by Nancy Pelosi, and began in February A formal impeachment investigation began in July ,  and several subpoenas were issued; while most were honored, several were not.
The Trump administration asserted executive privilege , which led to several lawsuits including In re: Don McGahn. The Trump—Ukraine scandal revolves around alleged efforts by U.
President Donald Trump to illegally coerce Ukraine and other foreign countries into providing damaging narratives about Democratic Party presidential primary candidate Joe Biden , as well as information relating to Russian interference in the United States elections.
Trump allegedly enlisted surrogates within and outside his official administration , including his personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani and Attorney General William Barr , to pressure Ukraine and other foreign governments to cooperate in investigating conspiracy theories concerning American politics.
A number of contacts were established between the White House and the government of Ukraine , culminating in a phone call between Trump and Zelensky on July 25, The scandal reached public attention in mid-September after a whistleblower complaint made in August A non-verbatim transcript of the Trump—Zelensky call confirmed that Trump requested investigations into Joe Biden and his son Hunter , as well as a discredited conspiracy theory involving a Democratic National Committee server,   while repeatedly urging Zelensky to work with Giuliani and Barr on these matters.
On the evening of September 24, , Pelosi announced that six committees of the House of Representatives would begin a formal impeachment inquiry into President Trump.
Pelosi accused the President of betraying his oath of office , national security , and the integrity of the country's elections.
In October , three congressional committees Intelligence, Oversight, and Foreign Affairs deposed witnesses including Ambassador Taylor,  Laura Cooper the deputy assistant secretary of defense for Russian, Ukrainian and Eurasian affairs ,  and former White House official Fiona Hill.
Get over it. On October 29, , Massachusetts representative Jim McGovern introduced a resolution referred to House Rules Committee, which set forth the "format of open hearings in the House Intelligence Committee, including staff-led questioning of witnesses, and [authorization for] the public release of deposition transcripts".
On November 13, Taylor and Kent testified publicly. On November 20, , Ambassador Sondland testified that he conducted his work with Giuliani at the "express direction of the president",  and that he understood a potential White House invitation for Zelensky to be contingent on Ukraine announcing investigations into the elections and Burisma.
Embassy in Ukraine. On December 3, the House Intelligence Committee voted 13—9 along party lines to adopt a final report and also send it to the House Judiciary Committee.
In furtherance of this scheme, President Trump conditioned official acts on a public announcement by the new Ukrainian President, Volodymyr Zelensky, of politically-motivated investigations, including one into President Trump's domestic political opponent.
The Republicans of the House committees had released a countering report the previous day, saying in part that the evidence does not support accusations.
On December 5, Speaker Pelosi authorized the Judiciary Committee to begin drafting articles of impeachment. A set of impeachment hearings was brought before the Judiciary Committee, with Trump and his lawyers being invited to attend.
After listening to him complain about the impeachment process, we had hoped that he might accept our invitation. The first hearing, held on December 4, , was an academic discussion on the definition of an impeachable offense.
Republicans invited Jonathan Turley , a constitutional scholar at George Washington University;   Turley, who had testified in favor of the impeachment of President Bill Clinton in ,   testified against impeaching Trump, citing a lack of evidence.
Potential articles of impeachment outlined during the hearing include abuse of power for arranging a quid pro quo with the president of Ukraine, obstruction of Congress for hindering the House's investigation, and obstruction of justice for attempting to dismiss Robert Mueller during his investigation of Russian interference in the election.
She also said, "I could not be prouder or more inspired by the moral courage of the House Democrats. We never asked one of them how they were going to vote.
We never whipped this vote. On December 10, , Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee announced they would levy two articles of impeachment, designated H.
Democrat Ted Lieu was ill and not present to vote. On December 16, the House Judiciary Committee released a page report on the articles of impeachment, specifying criminal bribery and wire fraud charges as part of the abuse of power article.
Article I, Section 2, Clause 5 of the U. Constitution states that "The House of Representatives On December 17, the House Rules Committee held a hearing to write the rules governing the debate over impeachment.
One of the highlights of this contentious event was Georgia representative Barry Loudermilk comparing the impeachment inquiry of President Trump to the trial of Jesus Christ , saying that the Christian savior was treated far better by the authorities.
It's what makes our two-party system function. It's what helps hold presidents and majorities accountable. But party loyalty must have its limits.
The formal impeachment vote in the House of Representatives took place on December 18, Days before the impeachment vote, it was leaked that Jeff Van Drew was planning on switching parties from Democratic to Republican.
Three representatives pending retirement did not vote: Duncan D. Serrano , who had a health setback after being diagnosed with Parkinson's disease earlier in the year; and John Shimkus , who was visiting his son in Tanzania.
A day after Trump's impeachment, the evangelical magazine Christianity Today published an editorial calling for his removal from office, stating that the president "attempted to use his political power to coerce a foreign leader to harass and discredit one of the president's political opponents.
That is not only a violation of the Constitution; more importantly, it is profoundly immoral. Trump has questioned the validity of the impeachment, citing Harvard law professor Noah Feldman , who argued that the impeachment has technically not taken place until the articles are handed to the Senate.
Also, very unfair with no Due Process, proper representation, or witnesses. Now Pelosi is demanding everything the Republicans weren't allowed to have in the House.
Dems want to run majority Republican Senate. Attorney George T. Conway III and others have noted that if the relevant witnesses are not allowed to testify, Trump's defenders will be negatively affected by "the very evidence they sought to suppress".
Prior to the House impeachment vote, McConnell and Senate Judiciary Committee chairman Lindsey Graham expressed their intentions not to be impartial jurors , contrary to the oath they must take.
This is a political process. There is not anything judicial about it. Impeachment is a political decision. I'm not trying to pretend to be a fair juror here I will do everything I can to make [the impeachment trial] die quickly.
On December 18, , the day of the impeachment, Pelosi declined to comment on when the impeachment resolution would be transmitted to the Senate, stating, "So far we haven't seen anything that looks fair to us.
On January 14, , Pelosi announced the House managers who would prosecute the case in the Senate. Later that afternoon, Pelosi held a rare public engrossment ceremony, followed by a stately procession of the managers and other House officers across the Capitol building, where the third impeachment of a U.
While the impeachment inquiry was underway, Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell started planning a possible trial. On October 8, , he led a meeting on the subject, advising his caucus to say that they opposed the House process and as little else as possible.
There will be no difference between the president's position and [ours]  I'm going to take my cues from the president's lawyers. The U. Constitution stipulates that the Chief Justice of the United States presides over impeachment proceedings.
Bush in Article I, Section 3, Clause 6 of the U. Constitution states that "[t]he Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments.
At the end of the session on January 21, the Senate voted along party lines to pass McConnell's proposed trial rules and reject 11 amendments proposed by Democrats.
The prosecution's opening arguments and presentation of evidence took place between January 22 and 24, The primary arguments were a lack of direct evidence of wrongdoing and that Democrats were attempting to use the impeachment to steal the election.
He observed that all politicians act with an eye and motive toward re-election and that such motive neither makes illegal acts lawful nor unlawful act legal.
On January 31, after a planned debate session, the Senate voted against allowing subpoenas to call witnesses, including former national security advisor John Bolton who wrote in his forthcoming book mentioning Ukraine aid freezing ,  or documents with a 51—49 vote.
Under the U. Constitution, a two-thirds majority of the Senate is required to convict the president. The possible penalties are the removal from office and disqualification from holding office in the future.
The votes were 52—48 to acquit on the first count and 53—47 to acquit on the second count. The votes were sharply divided along party lines. Before the trial, in mid-January , Americans were sharply divided on whether Trump should be removed from office, with Democrats largely supporting removal, Republicans largely opposing, and independents divided.
Two days after he was acquitted by the Senate in the impeachment trial, Trump fired two witnesses who testified in the impeachment inquiry about his conduct.
His honor, his commitment to right, frightened the powerful. In April , Trump fired Michael K. Atkinson , the inspector general of the intelligence community.
How can you [forward the complaint] without seeing the person? From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Members of House of Representatives vote on two articles of impeachment H.
Main article: Trump—Ukraine scandal. See also: Conspiracy theories related to the Trump—Ukraine scandal.
Whistleblower complaint dated August 12, , regarding a July 25 phone conversation between Trump and Zelensky. Play media. Main article: Impeachment inquiry against Donald Trump.
This article is part of a series about. President of the United States. Presidential campaigns. Interactions involving Russia. Business and personal.
Main article: Impeachment trial of Donald Trump. Clinton case over his testimony. Clinton ended up agreeing to a five-year suspension from practicing law in Arkansas.
Clinton would resigning from the bar during the appeal process of disbarment from the court. Of the 41 members, Ted Lieu , who represented California's 33rd , was ill and not present to vote, leaving 40 votes.
Being an even number, half plus one is needed for a majority, yielding 21 as the number of Aye votes for agreement.
Three members were not present for the vote: Duncan D. Serrano from New York's 15th was prevented from voting due to medical issues; and John Shimkus from Illinois's 15th was on personal trip to Tanzania.
This left votes but, being an even number, half plus one is needed for a majority, yielding as the number of yea votes for adoption.
According to a House Intelligence Committee official, this is evidence of the president's obstruction of Congress. This left votes, half of which rounded up yields as the number of yea votes for adoption.
There are Senate seats two per U. Two-thirds of is If the poll is within the doubled margin of error, both colors are used.
If the margin of error is, for example, 2. December 18, The New York Times. Retrieved December 18, November 7, Archived from the original on November 7, Retrieved November 26, Until Mitt Romney".
Washington Post. February 5, Retrieved February 6, February 7, Yet if you had forgotten this happened, it would be understandable.
The Biden campaign declined to comment for this piece. It may not have been all that effective, either.
While impeachment preoccupied politically involved Americans for months, polls show that after the initial proceedings, it did little to affect dug-in partisan views.
Taylor cited Sondland's telling him in a call that Trump wanted Zelensky to publicly announce he would order the two investigations, thus placing Zelensky "in a public box".
Taylor quoted Sondland as saying "everything" including military aid and a Trump—Zelensky meeting was contingent upon that announcement.
According to Taylor, he wrote a first-person cable to Secretary Pompeo on advice from Bolton: "I wrote and transmitted such a cable on August 29, describing the 'folly' I saw in withholding military aid to Ukraine at a time when hostilities were still active in the east and when Russia was watching closely to gauge the level of American support for the Ukrainian government.
I told the secretary that I could not and would not defend such a policy. Thirteen of those members participated in the protest. The House Judiciary Committee asked to see secret grand jury information that had been used in compiling the Mueller Report.
The DOJ refused to turn it over, arguing that secrecy of grand jury material must be preserved and that the impeachment inquiry was invalid. Howell ruled that the inquiry is valid and that the DOJ must forward the information to the committee within the week.
Some legal analysts noted that a White House counsel letter to Democratic leaders days earlier stating the administration would not cooperate with the impeachment inquiry—which was widely derided as more of a political rather than a legal argument—   may have backfired by contributing to Howell's rationale for her decision.
Charles Kupperman , Trump's deputy national security advisor from January to September , filed a lawsuit on October 25, , in which he asked a federal judge to rule which conflicting order he should follow: a subpoena from the House or an order from the White House not to appear.
His attorney said that as a private citizen Kupperman is not able to choose which directive to obey, adding that "Constitutional disputes between the Legislative and Executive Branches should be adjudicated by the Judicial Branch".
Vindman said that, additionally, he was concerned by two events, both of which he objected to senior officials in real-time, and which he reported to the NSC's lead attorney.
At the meeting, Sondland asked Ukraine to launch investigations into the Bidens to get a meeting with President Trump. Vindman states that Bolton cut the meeting short, and that both he and Fiona Hill told Ambassador Sondland his comments were inappropriate, and that he reported the concerns to the NSC's lead counsel.
The second event occurred on a July 25 phone call between President Trump and Zelensky. Vindman states, "I was concerned by the call.
I did not think it was proper to demand that a foreign government investigate a U. I realized that if Ukraine pursued an investigation into the Bidens and Burisma, it would likely be interpreted as a partisan play which would undoubtedly result in Ukraine losing the bipartisan support it has thus far maintained.
This would all undermine U. Vindman said he had tried but failed to restore the full transcript. Vindman also testified that the "rough transcript" of the July 25 phone call omitted President Zelensky stating the name Burisma the natural gas company on whose board Hunter Biden sat , and substituted it with the phrase "the company that you mentioned in this issue".
She noted in her opening statement that she was aware of Giuliani's communication with Volker, though she was not involved with those discussions, that former Republican lawmaker Bob Livingston repeatedly called her to promote the removal of Ambassador Yovanovitch.
The only reason given was that the order came in the direction of the President. Christopher J. Anderson , a career Foreign Service officer who succeeded Croft as an adviser to Volker, was also deposed the same day.
However, their efforts repeatedly conflicted with Giuliani's. However, the statement was blocked from publication by the White House. Morrison corroborated previous testimony by Bill Taylor , saying Taylor had been "accurate" on the "substance" of their conversations, but there were two differences in the details, the first being a location of a meeting.
Taylor's testimony was that Zelensky should make the announcement. He told lawmakers he "promptly" brought concerns about the call to White House lawyers because he worried a summary would be leaked with negative consequences, but he said he did not necessarily think anything illegal was discussed.
Like former deputy national security adviser Charles Kupperman, Blair is waiting for the courts to solve a conflict between the White House prohibition and a congressional subpoena.
The case is scheduled to be decided in December;   [ needs update ] the same month, Blair was promoted. On November 6, , David Hale, the undersecretary of State for political affairs, testified for several hours on the subject of the ouster of Yovanovitch.
On November 15, David Holmes, a U. Department of State foreign service officer who works at the U. The phone call being made in a public restaurant in Kyiv on unencrypted cell phones with Russian intelligence agents potentially listening to the conversation raised security concerns to some former diplomats and military officials.
I guarantee the Russians have the actual information. On November 4, , two transcripts of the closed-door depositions, those of Ambassadors Yovanovitch and McKinley, were released by the three presiding House committees.
Although the application was simply denied because of his corrupt dealings in Ukraine, the ambassador later learned he had lied on his application and that the true purpose of the visit was to meet with Giuliani and "provide information about corruption at the embassy, including my [alleged] corruption", she told the committees.
Giuliani lobbied the assistant secretary for consular affairs , conceding the true purpose of Shokin's planned visit to the U. The State Department meanwhile remained silent while she faced public attacks in an attempt to recall her to the U.
McKinley, a former ambassador and later senior adviser to Secretary Pompeo, testified that he had three times advised the Secretary of State to defend Yovanovitch after the July 25 call in which Trump disparaged her became public knowledge.
McKinley also said Kent was being pressured by State Department lawyers to remain silent and that Kent feared the State Department was relaying inaccurate information to Congress.
Transcripts of the depositions of Ambassadors Volker and Sondland were released on November 5, Sondland had originally claimed he "never" believed there were any preconditions for the release of military aid to Ukraine and that he "was dismayed when it was held up", but "didn't know why".
The transcript of Ambassador Taylor's deposition was also released on November 6. During his deposition on October 22, he described the campaign, led by Giuliani, to instigate investigations into the Bidens in Ukraine.
Taylor said it was his "clear understanding, security assistance money would not come until the [Ukrainian] president committed to pursue the investigation".
Following public release of the transcripts, Trump asserted they had been "doctored" by Schiff and encouraged Republicans to "put out their own transcripts!
On October 25, , Charles Kupperman, Trump's former deputy national security adviser, filed an advisory lawsuit, asking a D.
He said he will follow whatever the judge says. On October 31, Judge Richard J. Leon scheduled a hearing for December On November 9, former national security advisor John Bolton, who had joined in the Kupperman lawsuit, had his lawyer send a proffer to the committees, saying he could supply much additional pertinent information the committee did not have.
There were oral arguments on December 10,  and the case was dismissed on December 30, The Justice Department had claimed "absolute immunity".
On November 25 she ruled that he must testify, declaring that "no one is above the law," but that he could invoke executive privilege on certain questions.
The administration has appealed the ruling. House Democrats have requested the records from the grand jury proceedings that were part of the Mueller investigation , stating that the material was needed to investigate whether or not articles of impeachment should include perjury charges against the president based on his responses to the Mueller probe.
The district court decided in their favor, but two of the three judges on an appeals court panel seemed skeptical.
They set oral arguments for January 3, On January 3, lawyers for the House Judiciary Committee urged the court to enforce the subpoena against McGahn, arguing that McGahn's testimony could provide the basis for new articles of impeachment against the President.
On November 22, the State Department released pages of documents in response to a court order. The documents show that Giuliani and Pompeo spoke on the phone twice in late March, confirming a statement made by David Hale in his public testimony.
They also show that Trump's then-assistant Madeleine Westerhout helped to put Giuliani in touch with Pompeo.
Other FOIA requests have been made in related cases. On November 6, , Chairman Adam Schiff announced that the first public hearings of the impeachment inquiry would be held on November 13, beginning with Bill Taylor and George Kent.
Per the House of Representatives resolution adopted in October , Republican representatives can subpoena witnesses only with the concurrence of the Democratic committee chairman or with approval of the majority members.
In Schiff's decline of the request to hear from Biden, he said he would not allow Republicans to use the hearings to conduct "sham investigations".
As public hearings approached, a staff memo to Republican members of the three relevant committees outlined the major themes they should pursue in Trump's defense.Constitution, a two-thirds majority of the Senate is required to convict the president. The primary arguments were a lack of direct evidence of wrongdoing and that Democrats Oddset Online attempting to use the impeachment to steal the election. It's a matter of deliberation for the Senate. Deposed on October 14 . Acting White House Chief of Staff. February 5, Trump Impeached Jayapal. Schiff argued that the complaint might have been withheld from Congress "in an unlawful effort to protect the President and conceal from the Committee information related to his possible 'serious or flagrant' misconduct, abuse of power, or Bondora Go And Grow Erfahrung of law". Brian Fitzpatrick. Retrieved October 5, Lotto Sportwetten we work something out? Sign up. Maguire countered that the situation was unique since the complaint involves communications of the president. Archived from the original on December 16, President Donald J. Trump has been impeached. The House of Representatives voted on Wednesday, December 18, , to impeach Trump for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress and to send the. Background. Donald Trump is the third U.S. president to be impeached by the House of Representatives, after Andrew Johnson in and Bill Clinton in Before Trump, Johnson was the only president to be impeached in his first term. In historic vote, Trump acquitted of impeachment charges Democrats fall far short of the two-thirds needed to make the president, charged with abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, the first. Washingtn (CNN) President Donald Trump was impeached by the House of Representatives in a near party-line vote Wednesday. He is still the President. What comes next is a trial in the Senate early. Today: The United States House of Representatives has impeached President Trump for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. My colleague Lisa Chow and I on the story of how a fractious. With that, Donald J. Trump became the third president in American history to be impeached by the House of Representatives. archived recording (donald trump) With today’s illegal. After a long and tense debate on Capitol Hill, Democrats and Republicans voted on two articles to impeach the 45th president on abuse of power and obstructio. President Donald Trump is the third president in the history of the United States to be impeached by the House of Representatives. President Andrew Johnson was impeached in President Bill. Am 7. Dezember veröffentlichten die Demokraten des Justizausschusses einen Bericht mit dem Titel Constitutional grounds for presidential impeachment . Kann US-Präsident Donald Trump am Ende doch noch stürzen? Wird er selbst vorgeladen? Wie läuft das Verfahren ab? Wir geben Antworten. Niederlage für die Demokraten: Sie wollten im Impeachment-Verfahren gegen Donald Trump auch Zeugen hören. Erfolglos. Das Votum fiel. Kaum ist das Impeachment-Verfahren gegen US-Präsident Donald Trump beendet, nimmt dieser Rache an jenen, die gegen ihn ausgesagt hatten.